Google has backtracked on the look of Search results on the desktop platform, after it copped flak from users for masking ads as organic results. Several netizens said on Twitter that there was a "blurred line" between ads and organic results and does not allow users to clearly distinguish between the two.
The Search result’s visual refresh update was first unveiled on the mobile platform in May 2019. According to Google, the new design was created to allow a website’s branding to be front and centre, and letting users better understand where the information is coming from. The name of the website and its icon will appear at the top of the results card to anchor each result. In addition, a bolded “Ad” label will appear at the top of the results card alongside the web address to identify where the information is coming from.
Here is an example of how the Search results looked like previously (left), and what Google updated it into (right) on the mobile platform:
Last week, in a series of tweets, Google said that it will now experiment with new placements for favicons (website icon) and during these tests, some might not see favicons while some might see them in different placements.
The company said that it is looking to bring a modern look to desktop, and that its early tests of the design for desktop were positive. However, when the update was mirrored on desktop, there was a surge of comments around users not being unable to distinguish between ads and organic results. Some netizens also said they will switch to another search engine, while a handful of users said this would be a marketing opportunity for Bing.
In english, We are greedy and want you to click on more ads.
— D34TH0FKVorshk (@D34TH0FKVorshk) January 25, 2020
It literally hurts my eyes. Do you not beta test this stuff first? I mean damn... I gotta switch search engines if this doesn’t change.
— AJ (@prblyranting) January 18, 2020
Not really. These results are completely irrelevant to my search and seem mostly focused on advertising brands. Switching my default search engine today. #Fail
— April Moore (@AprilDMoore) January 22, 2020
This is literally the dumbest shit you've done and you need to undo it immediately. @bing this is a marketing opportunity
— Juan Q Public (@public_juan) January 18, 2020
To this Google said it has heard the feedback from users and the community, and is working to improve the experience.
Meanwhile, Google recently revealed that in two years, it plans to make third-party cookies obsolete on Chrome as part of its open source initiative, Privacy Sandbox, which was first announced in August last year. This comes as users are demanding greater privacy – including transparency, choice and control over how their data is used. Come February, Chrome will limit insecure cross-site tracking. Since the announcement, multiple media outlets including Reuters reported that adtech companies such as Criteo and Trade Desk Inc have been impacted, with their shares dipping 8% and 1.4% respectively. Nonetheless, industry players say it is a step in the right direction for Google.